A defect turns a tree into a hazard only when it has something to hit.
A tree is a hazard, in the USDA Forest Service's definition, when it has "structural defects likely to cause failure of all or part of the tree" and something within reach to strike, which the guide calls a target. A house, a car in the driveway or a yard where children play can be that target. The home page's fence-line check reads eight warning signs from the ground, in three tiers.
General field guidance, not a diagnosis from a distance. A tree can hide problems from the fence line and hide strengths too.
A hazard is a defect plus a target
The USDA Forest Service guide "How to Recognize Hazardous Defects in Trees" builds on that pairing. Its targets are concrete: "A target can be a vehicle, building, or a place where people gather such as a park bench, picnic table, street, or backyard." Its defects come in seven main types: dead wood, cracks, weak branch unions, decay, cankers, root problems and poor tree architecture.
The pairing cuts both ways: "A tree with defects is not hazardous, however, unless some portion of it is within striking distance of a target." Some targets move and some stay put, which is why the first question about any tree is what sits under it.
Call now: a lean that is new, and ground lifting at the base
The check's first tier starts with a lean that is new, read as Call now: a trunk that stood straight and now tilts has moved, and it still stands over whatever it leans toward. An old lean the tree grew into reads differently, and a tree starting to lean compares the two.
Roots work out of sight, so ground that rises, splits or mounds on one side of a trunk is one way a root failure shows, and the check reads it as Call now too. Lifted or cracked soil at the base of a tree separates that from clay that simply dries and cracks.
Both are views of one event: a tree shifting where it stands.
Worth a call: mushrooms, dead limbs, a cracked fork, bark over soft wood
The guide reads mushrooms, conks and brackets growing on root flares, stems or branches as indicators of advanced decay; mushrooms at the base of a tree tells those apart from the ones that come up in a lawn.
Dead trees and branches, in the guide's words, can "break and fall at any time," and of the large pieces it says "dead trees and large dead branches must be removed immediately." Big dead limbs weighs a dead limb by its size, its height and what lies below.
Two similar stems growing close together can trap bark in the joint, which the guide calls a weak branch union. It calls cracks "extremely dangerous because they indicate that the tree is already failing," a crack being "a deep split through the bark, extending into the wood of the tree." A crack at the fork reads that joint from the ground.
Bark leaving a trunk that held it is what the guide calls a canker, "a localized area on the stem or branch of a tree, where the bark is sunken or missing." Bark peeling off a tree sorts that from the bark that trees such as sycamore shed as they grow.
All four sit in the middle tier, Worth a call: each is trouble in the wood itself.
Worth watching: sawdust below, and limbs on the roof or the line
Sawdust gathering at the base of a tree comes from insects working in the wood it fell from, the debris NC State Extension says carpenter ants throw out as they dig. Ants on a trunk may only be foraging, and sawdust at the base of a tree traces a pile back to whatever made it.
A limb resting on the roof scratches at the shingles and can offer squirrels and carpenter ants a way to the house, and a limb across the wire to the house is a matter for the electric utility first; tree limbs touching the roof or the line to the house deals with both.
Neither is a defect in the wood on its own, which is why they sit at Worth watching, and either moves up when another sign joins it.
How to look a tree over from the ground
In the USDA Forest Service guide's advice, any time of year works, in leaf or bare; to be thorough, look after the leaves drop in fall, again after they come out in spring, and after severe storms. Take in every part, from the roots and the root flare, the swell where trunk meets roots, up the main stem to the branches and their joints, from every side, with binoculars for high limbs. Older trees, the guide says, may have collected several defects and extensive decay.
The method is eyes and the windows of the house; none of it needs a ladder, a pry bar or a shovel. After a storm, the storm's own hazards come first, as what not to touch after a storm lays them out, then the trees still standing, which the days after a storm works through.
What a look from the ground cannot settle
Decay inside a trunk can sit behind wood that looks sound, which dead and rotten trunks shows.
Defects that stack are another limit. The guide says "Multiple defects that are touching or are close to one another should be carefully examined," and "If more than one defect occurs on the tree's main stem, you should assume that the tree is extremely hazardous." A crack running into a canker reads as more than either alone.
The guide is plain about itself as well: it "presents guidelines, not absolute rules for recognizing and correcting hazardous defects," and says "Evaluating and treating hazard trees is complicated, requiring a certain knowledge and expertise."
Moving the target comes first; pruning and removal are the rest
Corrective actions, in the guide, begin with a thorough evaluation, and if a hazardous situation exists, "there are three recommended options for correcting the problem: move the target, prune the tree, or remove the tree." Moving the target is the one a homeowner can do today: "Easily moved items like play sets and swings, RV's, and picnic tables can be placed out of the reach of the hazardous tree." Where the target cannot be moved and a serious hazard exists, the guide says to "consider blocking access to the target area until the hazard can be properly eliminated."
The other two are tree work, and two of the crew's five services. Pruning fits a problem confined to a defective branch or branches, "even though the rest of the tree is sound," and is the work of tree trimming and pruning. Removal the guide calls "the final option," to be used "only when the other two corrective actions will not work," and "inherently dangerous and is even more serious when homes and other targets are involved": the work tree removal describes.
Whether a particular tree stays is settled by someone standing at it. The guide's own advice is "When in doubt, consult an arborist," and NC State Extension's routes for the close calls are given on emergency or Monday job triage.
Which signs did the fence-line check turn up?
Questions people actually ask.
Is a tree with a defect always a hazard?
No. The USDA Forest Service guide says a tree with defects "is not hazardous, however, unless some portion of it is within striking distance of a target," such as a building, a vehicle or a place where people gather.
How often does the Forest Service guide say to look a tree over?
Every year, in the USDA Forest Service guide's advice for trees under your responsibility, with extra looks after leaf drop in fall, after leaf-out in spring and after severe storms for a thorough job.
Does a hazard tree always have to come down?
No. The USDA Forest Service guide lists moving the target and pruning the tree ahead of removal, which it calls the final option, used only when the other two corrective actions will not work. Which applies to a given tree is settled at the tree.
What happens to the signs I tap on the fence-line check?
The fence-line check's Ask About These Signs button puts the signs you tap into the quote form on the home page, so the request reaches the crew already naming them.